Can Cloudshift blink a creature token back?

The scenario

You cast Cloudshift targeting an ordinary creature token you control. Cloudshift resolves and exiles that token. Does it return before state-based actions make it cease to exist?

Short answer

No. A token that has left the battlefield cannot move to another zone or return to the battlefield. That restriction applies during resolution, before the later state-based action makes the token cease to exist.

Step by step

1. The token is a legal creature target for Cloudshift. The first instruction exiles it.
2. Cloudshift then tries to return it during the same resolution. Rule 111.8 prevents a token that has left the battlefield from coming back, so it stays in exile.
3. After the spell finishes resolving, state-based actions are checked and the token in exile ceases to exist. The absence of a mid-resolution SBA check does not bypass the separate token movement rule.

What changes the answer?

A nontoken creature

A normal creature card can return under Cloudshift's instructions. It becomes a new object, with the usual consequences for counters, damage, and attachments.

A token dies instead

A token can go to a graveyard and cause death triggers before it ceases to exist. 'Tokens cannot return' is not the same as 'tokens never enter a graveyard.'

Rules and verification

Checked against the Comprehensive Rules effective 2026-09-25. Read the dated official source. Rule-browser links may use an older site snapshot; the dated official document is this scenario's verification source.

• CR 111.8: A token that left the battlefield cannot move again or return.
• CR 704.5d: A token outside the battlefield ceases to exist as a state-based action.
• CR 117.5: State-based actions happen before a player receives priority.

Card sources

Oracle text snapshot checked 2026-10-15. These quotations are card reference material, not original MtG-RC explanations.

More scenarios

• Does Giant Growth save a creature from Lightning Bolt? — Timing
• Does killing Prodigal Pyromancer stop its ability? — Timing
• Does Hex resolve if one of its six targets disappears? — Targets
• Whose death trigger resolves first in four-player Commander? — Multiplayer
• Does Blood Artist trigger under Rest in Peace? — Replacement effects
• Doubling Season and Hardened Scales: five counters or six? — Replacement effects
• If the blocker disappears, does the attacker hit the player? — Combat
• Why does Dismember kill an indestructible creature? — State-based actions
• What happens when Clone copies your own legendary creature? — Copies
• Does a commander die if you move it to the command zone? — Commander
• Humility plus Glorious Anthem: are your creatures 1/1 or 2/2? — Layers